November 3 ballot. What does the homestead amendment do to your tax bill? See your bill →
Putnam Realty GroupFlorida Home Value AI · Michael Putnam, Sales Associate
Home › Communities › Palmero vs Talon Preserve
Community Comparison · Nokomis, FL

Palmero vs Talon Preserve

Two of Nokomis's newest gated communities, compared on real recorded Sarasota County sales, not national averages.

In the past year, single-family homes in Talon Preserve sold at a median of $675,000, about $349 per Sq. Ft. In Palmero, the single-family median was $590,000, about $253 per Sq. Ft. Palmero’s single-family homes that sold were larger at the median (2,410 vs 2,040 Sq. Ft.), so buyers are weighing price per foot against total space.
Single-family homes sold by owners, recorded with Sarasota County October 3, 2025 through October 2, 2026. New homes sold by the builder aren’t counted. Palmero had 9 such sales and Talon Preserve 25, so treat the medians as a snapshot.

Side by side

 PalmeroTalon Preserve
Single-family homes sold, past year925
Single-family price range$455,000 to $680,000$485,900 to $1,450,000
Single-family median$590,000$675,000
Single-family price per Sq. Ft.$253$349
Single-family median size2,410 Sq. Ft.2,040 Sq. Ft.
Attached homes sold, past year2 townhomes, $278,400 to $325,0005 villas, $370,000 to $491,000
New homes sold by the builder, past year1168
Share of homes with a pool11%39%
Homes on the county roll306858

What the numbers say

The clearest difference is price per Sq. Ft.: single-family homes in Talon Preserve sold for about $349 a foot against Palmero’s $253. Total price tells a subtler story. Palmero’s homes that sold ran larger, so a bigger Palmero home can land near a smaller Talon home on total price while costing much less per foot. Pools are far more common in Talon (39% of homes against 11%), which lifts its numbers.

Palmero and Talon Preserve are at different stages with their builders. Taylor Morrison has finished selling in Palmero, with 1 new home sold in the past year, so nearly every sale there is a resale. DiVosta is still selling in Talon Preserve, with 168 new homes sold in the past year against 30 owner sales, so an owner selling in Talon competes with brand-new homes. For a specific home in either community, the estimate below gives a number right away, and I can refine it with what the data can’t see.

Get an estimated value range

Value a Palmero home → Value a Talon Preserve home →
Weighing Nokomis communities? Talk it through in my Facebook group: North Port & SW Florida Real Estate.

Common questions

Is Palmero or Talon Preserve more expensive?

Talon Preserve. In the past year, its single-family homes sold at a median of $675,000, about $349 per Sq. Ft., against $590,000 and about $253 per Sq. Ft. in Palmero, according to Sarasota County records. Palmero’s homes that sold were larger at the median, so total price and price per foot point different directions.

Which community has larger homes?

Palmero, among the single-family homes that sold in the past year: a median of about 2,410 Sq. Ft. against about 2,040 in Talon Preserve, based on county records.

Is the builder still selling?

In Talon Preserve, yes. DiVosta sold 168 new homes there in the past year. In Palmero, Taylor Morrison sold 1, so nearly every sale is now a resale.

Where are Palmero and Talon Preserve located?

Both are gated communities in Nokomis, FL (Sarasota County), near the 34275 area, a short drive from Venice, the Legacy Trail, and Gulf beaches.

Questions? Talk to Michael.

Call or text 941-662-9941 · [email protected]

Call or textEmail Michael