Community Comparison · Nokomis, FL

Palmero vs Talon Preserve

Q: Which Nokomis community has larger homes, Palmero or Talon Preserve?

Palmero at the median, about 2,632 square feet versus roughly 1,909 in Talon Preserve, based on recorded sales.

Two of Nokomis's newest gated communities, compared on real recorded Sarasota County sales, not national averages.

Over the past year, Talon Preserve homes sold at a higher median ($639,400) and a notably higher price per square foot ($323) than Palmero ($556,850, $196/sq ft). But Palmero's homes are larger at the median (2,632 vs 1,909 sq ft), so buyers are weighing price per foot against total space. Both are new-construction communities still being built out.

Recorded sale prices from Sarasota County public records. Palmero as of May 2026 (24 sales); Talon Preserve as of June 2026 (131 sales). Smaller sample sizes reflect how new these communities are.

Side by side

	Palmero	Talon Preserve
Median sale price	$556,850	$639,400
Price per sq ft	$196	$323
Single-family median	$565,000	$724,650
Median home size	2,632 sqft	1,909 sqft
Homes with a pool	11%	41%
Typical price range	$325K–$669K	$385K–$1.15M
Homes in community	306	795
Built	2021–2025	2020–2025
Sales past year	24	131

What the numbers say

The clearest difference is price per square foot: Talon Preserve commands about $323 versus Palmero's $196. But total price tells a subtler story, because Palmero's homes run larger at the median, a bigger Palmero home can land near a smaller Talon home on total price while costing much less per foot. Pools are also more common in Talon (41% vs 11%), which lifts its numbers, since pool homes sell at a premium.

Both communities are new and still selling, so their recorded sales include a mix of resales and builder closings, and the sample is smaller than an established neighborhood. Treat these as a current snapshot, not a long trend. For a specific home in either community, the estimate tool below gives an instant number, and I can refine it with what the data can't see.

Get an instant estimate

Value a Palmero home → Value a Talon Preserve home →

Weighing Nokomis communities? Talk it through in my Facebook group: North Port & SW Florida Real Estate.

Common questions

Is Palmero or Talon Preserve more expensive?

Talon Preserve had a higher median sale price ($639,400) and a higher price per square foot ($323) than Palmero ($556,850, $196/sq ft) over the past year in Sarasota County records. However, Palmero's homes are larger at the median, so total price and price per foot point different directions.

Which community has larger homes?

Palmero, at the median. Palmero's median home was about 2,632 square feet versus roughly 1,909 in Talon Preserve, based on recorded sales.

Are these new-construction communities?

Yes. Both were built primarily from 2020 onward and are still being built out, so recorded sales include builder closings alongside resales, and sample sizes are smaller than established neighborhoods.

Where are Palmero and Talon Preserve located?

Both are gated communities in Nokomis, FL (Sarasota County), near the 34275 area, a short drive from Venice, the Legacy Trail, and Gulf beaches.