Palmero Homes for Sale

What Palmero homes have actually sold for

These are recorded closing prices from Sarasota County public records: what buyers paid, not what sellers asked. This section contains no MLS data. Builder closings are excluded, because a builder's price isn't a comparable sale for a home that's already been lived in.

In the past year in Palmero, 9 single-family homes sold, for $455,000 to $680,000, and 2 townhomes sold, for $278,400 to $325,000.

Two sales worth a second look: 5601 and 5604 Blue Reef Place sold one day apart in April 2026, both 2,410 Sq. Ft., on the same street. The one with a pool sold for $31,000 more, on the smaller lot.

What a buyer would pay in property tax. A purchase resets the taxable value to about 89% of the price, so the seller's current bill doesn't carry over. For a single-family home in Palmero bought at $630,000, yearly property tax would be about $6,433 without a homestead exemption, or about $6,004 for a buyer who makes it their primary home, before the flat charges for fire rescue, solid waste and stormwater. Palmero is taxed as unincorporated Sarasota County. Work out any price in the tax calculator →

Sarasota County public records, qualified sales recorded October 3, 2025 through October 2, 2026. Figures are for general market awareness and are not appraisals. See every recorded Palmero sale, and look up what your own Palmero home is worth →